Skip to main content
Homepage
Full 18-step deep-dive · ~20–30 min · a member feature.
FRESH Analysis Report
Aug 9, 2026
today · 100% complete
For AI assistants & researchers — machine-readable summary of this page

What this page is: Delvantic's full research page for The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. (PNC) — AI-driven forensic equity research: mechanical valuation models (DCF, EPV, anchored-PE, scenario) plus three independent AI lenses (Quality / Value / Sentiment). Everything below is rendered server-side; you are not missing content that requires JavaScript. All scores are predictions and research opinions, not financial advice.

Our current read (analysis of 2026-08-09): Designation Watch · Cairn score -1 (−100…+100 Quality+Value blend) · Quality 42 · Value -37 · Sentiment 33 (timing only, not weighted) · Composite fair value $252.17 vs $252.56 at analysis

Page map (sections in order; each card carries a stable reference-name attribute you can cite):

  • profile-header / price-overview — company profile, live quote, market cap
  • extended-analysisthe core: three AI lens reads with findings, scores, and the analyst memo
  • future-predictions — our forward price-band predictions
  • market-narrative / ai-findings / gpt-critique — narrative context, cross-model findings, and an adversarial critique of our own analysis (near the end of the document)
  • Members-only sections (render as login gates for anonymous readers): price-history, income-trend, key-metrics, financials (statement tables), insider-trading. The analysis above is public; the raw data tables require a free account.

More for machine readers: site briefing at /llms.txt · any ticker resolves at delvantic.com/stock/TICKER · raw inputs are public-company filings and market data (via licensed data feeds); every model, score, lens read, and prediction on this page is Delvantic's own analysis.

The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.

PNC NYSE GICS Category PDF
Financial Services · Banks - Regional
Pittsburgh, PA 15222-2401, United States pnc.com Updated Aug 9, 12:07am
Price
$252.56
Market Cap
$100.8B
Employees
53,686
Beta
0.90
Avg Volume
1,898,596
Last Dividend
$7.10
CEO
Mr. William S. Demchak

The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. is a diversified financial services holding company based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The company provides a broad range of banking and financial solutions to retail, small business, corporate, and institutional clients across the United States. Its core activities are organized through retail banking, corporate and institutional banking, and an asset management group, supported by other related operations. Retail banking offers deposit accounts, consumer and small business lending, residential mortgages, and cash management, as well as brokerage and investment services. Corporate and institutional banking focuses on lending, treasury management, and capital markets products for mid-sized and large companies, public sector entities, and not-for-profit organizations. The asset management group delivers personal wealth management for high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth clients, along with institutional asset management services such as investment advisory and fiduciary solutions. Through this diversified platform, The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. plays a significant role in the U.S. regional banking and financial services landscape.

Runs with full report Generated: Aug 9, 2026 12:18am
Earnings Schedule
Checked daily · calendar updated Aug 9
No upcoming print on the calendar yet — companies typically confirm a few weeks ahead. Last print was Jul 15, 2026.
EPS surprise history — vs analyst consensus · 5 prints of vendor history
-4.7%
Nov '25
+15.9%
Jan '26
+18.2%
Feb '26
+4.6%
Apr '26
+8.1%
Jul '26
Print date EPS est. EPS actual Revenue est. Revenue actual
Jul 15, 2026 $4.45 $4.81 +8.1%
Apr 15, 2026 $3.95 $4.13 +4.6%
Feb 5, 2026 $0.88 $1.04 +18.2%
Jan 16, 2026 $4.21 $4.88 +15.9%
Nov 4, 2025 $3.16 $3.01 -4.7%

Green = beat the estimate, red = missed. An earnings print is the fastest way a thesis changes — our designations should be re-read after each one.

Recent SEC Filings
Filed Form Document
Aug 7, 2026 13F-HR View
Aug 7, 2026 SCHEDULE 13G/A View
Aug 7, 2026 SCHEDULE 13G View
Aug 7, 2026 SCHEDULE 13G View
Aug 7, 2026 SCHEDULE 13G/A View
Aug 7, 2026 SCHEDULE 13G View
Aug 5, 2026 10-Q View
Jul 24, 2026 4 View
Jul 22, 2026 144 View
Jul 21, 2026 8-K View
Jul 17, 2026 424B2 View
Jul 16, 2026 FWP View

Filings link to the SEC’s EDGAR system. Annual/quarterly reports (10-K, 10-Q, 20-F) carry the full story; 8-K/6-K current reports are the fastest signal that something material happened.

Price Overview
Price at report time
$252.56
as of Aug 9, 12:26am (3h ago)
Change · Aug 9
-0.20 (-0.08%)
Day Range
$249.54 – $253.18
52-Week Range
$176.88 – $258.13
50-Day MA
$242.70
200-Day MA
$218.31
Volume
956,200.00
Right now · live
loading…
 
Real-time — the change above is the move since the report (over 3h).
Share Structure
Outstanding 399,000,000.00
Float 395,963,558.00
Free Float 99.2%
High free float — 99.2% of shares trade freely, ~0.8% held by insiders/institutions
Very liquid — most shares trade freely. Low insider ownership can mean less management alignment, but makes large position sizing straightforward.
Price History (1 Year)
Last updated: Aug 9, 2026 12:29am (3h ago)
Revenue & Net Income Trend
The directional story — useful even when net income is negative.
Last updated: Aug 7, 2026 5:52am (1d ago)
Revenue
The top line — total sales before any costs or taxes are subtracted. A measure of how much business the company is doing.
Net Income
The bottom line — profit left after subtracting all expenses, interest, and taxes from revenue. Reflects accounting profitability, but includes non-cash items like depreciation, so it isn't the same as cash earned.
Operating Cash Flow
The real cash generated by the day-to-day business — selling products, paying suppliers, collecting from customers. Calculated from net income by adding back non-cash items and adjusting for timing (unpaid bills, unsold inventory). When OCF consistently lags net income, the reported profit may not be converting to real money.
Period Revenue Net Income Net Margin YoY/QoQ
Key Metrics
TD Twelve Data statement HEX SEC filing
Industry comparison last run: Aug 9, 2026 12:16am
P/E Ratio (Price per dollar of earnings)
HEX
Stock Price / EPS (Diluted)
15.22
Stock Price: $252.56
EPS (Diluted): 16.59
P/B Ratio (Price vs net asset value)
HEX
Stock Price / Book Value Per Share
1.74
Stock Price: $252.56
Total Equity: $60.64B
Shares: 418,083,183
EV/EBITDA (Total value vs operating profit)
HEX
Enterprise Value / EBITDA
Market Cap: $100.77B
Total Debt: $57.10B
Cash: $39.71B
EBITDA: N/A
EBITDA not available
Enterprise Value (Takeover price (cap + debt - cash))
HEX
Market Cap + Total Debt - Cash
$119.2B
Market Cap: $100.77B
Total Debt: $57.10B
Cash: $39.71B
Gross Margin (Revenue left after direct costs)
HEX
Gross Profit / Revenue
Gross Profit: N/A
Revenue: $23.08B
Missing from API: Gross Profit
Operating Margin (Revenue left after all operations)
HEX
Operating Income / Revenue
Operating Income: N/A
Revenue: $23.08B
Missing from API: Operating Income
Net Margin (Revenue left as actual profit)
HEX
Net Income / Revenue
30.1%
Net Income: $6.94B
Revenue: $23.08B
ROE (Profit from shareholder equity)
HEX
Net Income / Total Equity
11.4%
Net Income: $6.94B
Total Equity: $60.64B
ROIC (Profit from all invested capital)
HEX
NOPAT / Invested Capital
Operating Income: N/A
Tax Rate: 17.5%
Equity: $60.64B
Total Debt: $57.10B
Cash: $39.71B
Missing from API: Operating Income
Current Ratio (Can it pay short-term bills)
HEX
Current Assets / Current Liabilities
Current Assets: N/A
Current Liabilities: N/A
Missing from API: Current Assets, Current Liabilities
Debt/Equity (Leverage — debt vs equity)
HEX
Total Debt / Total Equity
0.94
Short-Term Debt: $0.00
Long-Term Debt: $57.10B
Total Debt: $57.10B
Total Equity: $60.64B
Rev/Share (Top-line per share)
HEX
Revenue / Shares Outstanding
$55.20
Revenue: $23.08B
Shares: 418,083,183
Book Value/Share (Net assets per share)
HEX
(Total Assets - Total Liabilities) / Shares
$145.03
Total Equity: $60.64B
Shares: 418,083,183
FCF/Share (Real cash generated per share)
HEX
(Operating Cash Flow + CapEx) / Shares
$10.49
Operating CF: $4.38B
CapEx: $0.00
Shares: 418,083,183
Div Yield (Annual income from holding)
TD
Last Annual Dividend / Stock Price
2.8%
Last Dividend: $7.10
Stock Price: $252.56
Payout Ratio (Earnings paid out as dividends)
HEX
Dividends Paid / Net Income
38.0%
Dividends Paid: -$2.64B
Net Income: $6.94B
Industry Benchmarks
Last run: Aug 9, 2026 12:14am
Compares PNC against LLM-researched typical ranges for its industry. One research call per industry, cached indefinitely — every stock in the same industry reuses the same baseline.
Income Statement (Annual)
Last updated: Aug 7, 2026 5:52am (1d ago)
Metric 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Revenue $19.2B $21.1B $21.5B $20.8B $23.1B
Cost of Revenue
Gross Profit
Operating Expenses $7.5B $7.6B $7.8B $7.7B $8.2B
Operating Income
Net Income $5.7B $6.0B $5.6B $5.9B $6.9B
EBITDA
EPS $12.71 $13.86 $12.80 $13.76 $16.60
EPS (Diluted) $12.70 $13.85 $12.79 $13.74 $16.59
Balance Sheet (Annual)
Last updated: Aug 6, 2026 7:31am (2d ago)
Metric 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Cash & Equivalents $8.0B $7.0B $6.9B $46.3B $39.7B
Total Current Assets
Total Assets $557.2B $557.3B $561.6B $560.0B $573.6B
Current Liabilities
Long-Term Debt $58.7B $72.7B $61.7B $57.1B
Total Liabilities $501.5B $511.5B $510.4B $505.6B $512.9B
Total Equity $55.7B $45.8B $51.1B $54.5B $60.6B
Retained Earnings $50.2B $53.6B $56.3B $59.3B $63.3B
Cash Flow (Annual)
Last updated: Aug 7, 2026 5:52am (1d ago)
Metric 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Operating Cash Flow $7.2B $9.1B $10.1B $7.9B $4.4B
Capital Expenditure
Free Cash Flow
Acquisitions (net) -$10.5B
Net Debt Issued / (Repaid)
Dividends Paid -$2.1B -$2.4B -$2.5B -$2.5B -$2.6B
Stock Buybacks -$1.1B -$3.7B -$651.0M -$687.0M -$1.3B
Net Change in Cash $987.0M -$961.0M -$122.0M -$4.5B -$6.5B
Growth Trends (YoY %)
Last updated: Aug 7, 2026 5:52am (1d ago)
Metric 2022 2023 2024 2025
Revenue Growth +9.9% +1.9% -3.3% +10.9%
Gross Profit Growth
Operating Income Growth
Net Income Growth +6.5% -7.7% +5.6% +17.8%
EBITDA Growth
Dividend History (Last 20)
Last updated: Aug 6, 2026 7:31am (2d ago)
Date Dividend Declaration Record Payment
2026-07-20 $2.00
2026-04-14 $1.70
2026-01-20 $1.70
2025-10-14 $1.70
2025-07-15 $1.70
2025-04-16 $1.60
2025-01-15 $1.60
2024-10-16 $1.60
2024-07-15 $1.60
2024-04-12 $1.55
2024-01-12 $1.55
2023-10-16 $1.55
2023-07-14 $1.55
2023-04-17 $1.50
2023-01-13 $1.50
2022-10-14 $1.50
2022-07-12 $1.50
2022-04-12 $1.50
2022-01-14 $1.25
2021-10-14 $1.25
Insider Trading (Recent)
Last updated: Aug 9, 2026 12:21am (3h ago)
Type codes PPurchase SSale AAward / grant MOption exercise FIn-kind (tax) CConversion GGift DReturn to issuer
All SEC Form 4 codes
Open market
P Purchase
Open-market or private purchase of shares.
S Sale
Open-market or private sale of shares.
Compensation (Rule 16b-3)
A Award / grant
Grant or award of securities (RSUs, options, etc.) under Rule 16b-3.
D Return to issuer
Securities disposed back to the company under Rule 16b-3.
F In-kind (tax)
Shares withheld or delivered to pay the option-exercise price or tax — not an open-market sale.
I Discretionary
Discretionary transaction under an employee plan — Rule 16b-3(f).
M Option exercise
Exercise or conversion of a derivative (option/RSU) into shares — exempt.
Derivatives
C Conversion
Conversion of a derivative security into the underlying shares.
E Short expiration
Expiration of a short derivative position.
H Long expiration
Expiration or cancellation of a long derivative position with value received.
O OTM exercise
Exercise of an out-of-the-money derivative.
X ITM exercise
Exercise of an in-the-money or at-the-money derivative.
Other exempt
G Gift
Bona fide gift of securities.
L Small acquisition
Small acquisition under Rule 16a-6.
W Inheritance
Acquisition or disposition by will or the laws of descent.
Z Voting trust
Deposit into or withdrawal from a voting trust.
Other
J Other
Other acquisition or disposition (explained in a Form 4 footnote).
K Equity swap
Transaction in an equity swap or similar instrument.
U Tender / buyout
Disposition via tender of shares in a change-of-control transaction.

Compensation-plan codes (A, D, F, M) are routine and rarely directional. Open-market P (buy) and S (sale) carry the most signal.

Date Insider Type Shares Price Value
2026-07-22 Deborah Guild S-Sale 1,200.00 $252.20 $302,634
2026-07-22 Deborah Guild G-Gift 72.00 $0.00 $0
2026-07-01 Feldstein Andrew T A-Award 392.00 $251.62 $98,635
2026-07-01 HESSE DANIEL A-Award 156.00 $251.62 $39,253
2026-07-01 CAFARO DEBRA A A-Award 303.00 $251.62 $76,241
2026-07-01 NIBLOCK ROBERT A A-Award 102.00 $251.62 $25,665
2026-07-01 HARSHMAN RICHARD J A-Award 91.00 $251.62 $22,897
2026-07-01 Dachille Douglas A. A-Award 51.00 $251.62 $12,833
2026-07-01 Salesky Bryan Scott A-Award 184.00 $251.62 $46,298
2026-07-01 Khator Renu A-Award 204.00 $251.62 $51,330
Deep Analysis
Last run: Aug 9, 2026 12:26:25 am

Pre-flight intelligence scans the company first, then routes to the right analytical methods.

0 Company Classification — What type of company is this?
1 Industry Landscape — Where is the industry headed?
2 Company Momentum — Where is this company trending?
3 Forward Projection — 1Y & 2Y projected metrics (requires Layer 1 + 2)
4a DCF Valuation — Present value of future cash flows
4b Earnings Power Value — Floor value — worth with zero growth
4c Anchored PE — Industry PE adjusted for growth differential
4d Reverse DCF — What growth is the market pricing in?
4e Revenue-Based DCF — For growth/narrative companies (skip if mature earner)
Not applicable for Mature Earner companies
4f Anchored P/S — Price-to-Sales peer comparison (skip if mature earner)
Not applicable for Mature Earner companies
4g Scenario Analysis — Bull / Base / Bear (skip if mature earner)
Not applicable for Mature Earner companies
4h Dividend Discount Model — For dividend/income stocks only
Not applicable for Mature Earner companies
4i Book Value Analysis — For deep value / turnaround stocks only
Not applicable for Mature Earner companies
4j Insider Activity — Are insiders buying or selling?
4f Cash Flow Quality — How trustworthy is the FCF?
4g Debt Maturity Risk — Can it handle its debt?
4h Macro Environment — Rates, market valuation, volatility
4i Sector Intelligence — How does this company compare within its sector?
4j Revenue Confidence — How reliable is the growth projection?
4k Sensitivity Analysis — How fragile is the fair value estimate?
4l Sector Demand Cycle — Is the sector in a boom, steady state, or contraction?
5 AI Investigation — Adaptive research engine (Claude)
5b Thesis Evaluation — What does the market believe? (narrative/platform stocks only)
Not applicable for Mature Earner companies
6 Valuation Synthesis — Weighted verdict from all methods (requires Layer 4)
Narrative Economics
The story the market is telling about this stock — the intangible X-factor (founder mythology, cult dynamics, TAM-of-imagination) that moves price beyond what cash flows alone explain. After Shiller, Narrative Economics.
No narrative profile yet for PNC — it's generated by the pipeline (market-narrative step).
Claude Reading
Independent analyst synthesis · claude-opus-4-7 · generated 2026-08-09 00:29:38
Verdict Modestly undervalued given accelerating quarterly trajectory — fair value $270-285 if Q3'26 confirms the run-rate; starter position at $252, add on confirmation or a $230 pullback.

Looking at the raw numbers first: revenue has stepped up sequentially every quarter since late 2024 — $5.43B → $5.45B → $5.66B → $5.92B → $6.07B → $6.17B → $6.88B — that's a genuine acceleration, not a plateau, with Q2'26 up 21.6% YoY. Net income where reported ($2.04B in Q2'26 vs $1.63B in Q2'25) shows 25% YoY earnings growth, and the 29.7% net margin is the highest print in the series. Annual NI trajectory $5.58B → $5.89B → $6.94B is 11.5% CAGR with acceleration in the most recent year. At 15.2x trailing P/E, 1.74x P/B, and 11.4% ROE with a 2.8% yield, this doesn't look like a stock priced for GDP growth — it looks like a bank priced roughly at its historical mid-range, with recent operating results outpacing that pricing.

The Market Forces module calling this a "value trap with unsustainable cyclically-peak earnings" is directly contradicted by the quarterly trajectory in the file. If earnings were peaking on reserve releases and NIM expansion, you'd expect sequential flatness or decline in a rate-cut environment — instead Q2'26 revenue jumped $710M sequentially (+11.5% QoQ). That's not reserve-release noise; that's spread income and fee income both working. The Market Forces verdict also cites "negative FCF generation" — for a bank, operating cash flow ($4.38B) minus effectively zero capex is the wrong frame; banks generate returns through balance sheet deployment, not FCF conversion. This looks like a template being misapplied to a bank. The Synthesis fair-value verdict ($254.69 vs $252.56) is defensible on multiples but doesn't credit the accelerating trajectory; the Narrative module's "anchored / no premium" read is the most honest characterization in the stack.

The contrarian bear case that actually has teeth: (1) the debt-to-equity of 0.94 and ROA of 1.21% are typical for banks but mean small credit deterioration cascades — CRE exposure at regional banks remains the unresolved 2023-2024 overhang, and PNC's Q2'26 strength could be flattered by pre-provisioning behavior; (2) held-to-maturity securities marks — not disclosed in this file — remain the hidden capital hole that bit SVB and could compress tangible book if realized; (3) the 11.4% ROE is fine but not exceptional, and 15.2x P/E is a full multiple for a bank compounding book value in the high single digits. The insider activity is unhelpfully small (1,200 share sale, routine awards) — no signal either way. Data gaps I'd flag: no gross/operating margin lines (normal for banks but limits cross-checking), no NIM disclosure, no NCO or provision detail, no CET1 ratio, and no HTM mark-to-market. For a regional bank in 2026, those are the four numbers that matter and none are here.

My read: I partially dissent from the Synthesis fair-value verdict and strongly dissent from Market Forces. The quarterly acceleration is real and inconsistent with a "peak earnings" narrative — if 2026 full-year earnings annualize from the $2.04B Q2 run-rate (call it $7.8-8.2B allowing for seasonality), forward P/E is closer to 12-13x, not 15.2x trailing. That's a modest discount to fair value, not a premium. Fair value on my read is $270-285 assuming the trajectory holds through one more print, with downside to $220 if Q3 shows NIM rollover or a credit surprise. The thesis hinges on Q3'26 — does the sequential revenue growth continue or was Q2 a one-off? I'd take a starter position here with the plan to add on either (a) confirmation next quarter or (b) a pullback to $230 that doesn't come with fundamental deterioration. The risk-reward is asymmetric to the upside from current levels given the earnings momentum the market hasn't fully repriced, but conviction is capped by the missing bank-specific disclosures (NIM, CRE, HTM marks) that would let me size this properly.

GPT Reading
Independent reading · gpt-5.4 · generated 2026-08-09 00:29:51
Verdict Fairly valued around $253 — the earnings trend is better than the bear case admits, but 15x earnings and 1.74x book already price in most of the recovery; upside looks limited unless quarterly profit holds near $2B.

The numbers say PNC is improving, but not mispriced. The most important change in the data is that revenue has clearly re-accelerated: from $5.43B in 2024-09 to $5.57B in 2024-12, $5.45B in 2025-03, $5.66B in 2025-06, $5.92B in 2025-09, $6.07B in 2025-12, $6.17B in 2026-03, and then a sharp step-up to $6.88B in 2026-06. That latest quarter is up 21.6% from the $5.66B posted a year earlier. Net income also moved from $1.63B to $2.04B over the same Q2 comparison, with margin expanding from 28.7% to 29.7%. On a full-year basis, 2025 revenue of $23.08B was up 10.9% from $20.81B in 2024, and net income of $6.94B was up 17.8% from $5.89B. This is not a bank rolling over at the first hint of rate pressure; it is still showing operating leverage and decent profitability.

That said, valuation already reflects a lot of that recovery. At $252.56, PNC is on 15.2x earnings and 1.74x book, which is not distressed-regional-bank pricing, and not even especially cheap for a bank earning 11.4% ROE. The simple spread that matters is this: a 1.74x P/B multiple against an 11.4% ROE implies investors are paying a meaningful premium to book for returns that are solid but not exceptional. If ROE were sustainably 14%-16%, I could justify leaning harder bullish at this multiple; at 11%-12%, it looks more like fair compensation for quality, diversification, and perceived balance-sheet resilience. The balance sheet supports that middle-of-the-road conclusion: $57.1B of debt against $39.7B of cash and $60.6B of equity is acceptable, not alarming, and the 2.8% dividend yield with a 38% payout ratio is comfortable. But comfort is different from upside.

What stands out to me is the mismatch between the strongest bearish narrative and the actual reported trajectory. A lot of the anti-bank case here depends on “peak earnings” and imminent net interest margin compression, yet the reported numbers through mid-2026 still show rising quarterly revenue and expanding profitability. If there is pressure building, it is not yet visible in headline results. At the same time, the bullish case also overreaches when it treats this as a compounding franchise worthy of a premium growth multiple. Revenue CAGR over the broader period is only 3.6%, and annual revenue in 2023 was actually higher than 2024 before rebounding in 2025. This is still a cyclical earnings engine, not a secular grower. The market has mostly split the difference correctly: it is paying up for stability, but not assigning a heroic multiple.

The best case against my fair-value read is that the market may still be underestimating just how much earnings power has improved. If the $2.04B quarterly net income run-rate were even close to sustainable, PNC would be earning above $8B annually rather than the $6.94B posted in 2025, which would make today’s $100.8B market cap look more like 12x forward earnings than 15x trailing. In that scenario, 1.74x book would not look expensive for a bank with strengthening margins, a conservative payout ratio, and enough capital flexibility to keep returning cash. The sequential revenue trend from $5.45B in 2025-03 to $6.88B in 2026-06 is strong enough that a bull can credibly argue consensus is still anchored to an outdated “normalization” framework. I weigh that less heavily because one strong quarter does not erase the basic fact that this is a rate-sensitive regional bank with only mid-teens-or-below return characteristics, and because cash generation is not obviously screamingly strong relative to earnings: 2025 operating cash flow was just $4.38B against $6.94B of net income.

What would change my mind is straightforward. I would turn bullish if the next couple of quarters hold revenue above roughly $6.5B and net income around or above $1.9B, showing that the $6.88B quarter was not a one-off and that ROE is moving materially above 12%. I would also get more constructive if book value growth starts catching up with the stock’s premium valuation, making 1.74x book easier to defend. I would turn bearish if revenue slips back toward the low-$6B range, if margins retreat below 28%, or if annualized earnings power proves closer to $7B than $8B-plus; at that point, paying 15x earnings and 1.7x book for a regional bank would look full.

Grok Reading
Grok (xAI) reads the identical raw briefing blind — one of the Big-3 independent readings — and commits to its own verdict.
No Grok reading yet for PNC — it's generated by the pipeline (grok-critique step) alongside the other Big-3 seats, when a report is run on this ticker.
Big-3 Panel — where each AI stands
Each AI above independently stated a direction (undervalued, fairly valued, or overvalued) and how strongly it believes it (conviction, 0–5). We combine those into a Bull-Bear Index on a 0–10 scale: 5 is neutral, 10 is maximum bullish (undervalued at full conviction), 0 is maximum bearish. We compute the score ourselves with the same arithmetic for every seat — the models never grade their own bullishness — so the three are directly comparable. Δ shows how far each seat sits from the panel average of 6.5; a large Δ marks the dissenting voice, usually the one worth reading.
Claude claude-opus-4-7 8.0
undervalued · conviction 3/5 · Δ +1.5 vs panel · self: 6.0
GPT gpt-5.4 5.0
fairly valued · conviction 4/5 · Δ -1.5 vs panel · self: 5.0
No second round needed — Panel agreed within band (spread 1: Claude: undervalued · GPT: fairly_valued) — second round not warranted
Advanced Analysis Forensic deep-dive · three lenses
Three separate reads — Company Quality (is it a great business?), Valuation (is it mispriced?), and General Sentiment (how macro + narrative are pushing it), kept deliberately apart · 2026-08-09 00:47:34
Delvantic - Cairn AI
Quality - wait for a dip 7/10
Solid super-regional bank (quality +42) trading right on top of deserved value (-37, FV ~$252) with a mild tape tailwind (+33) - a fine hold, not a buy here.
The cruxEntry price. The business is fine; the question is whether you pay full retail at $252 or wait for the ~$215 level where a real margin of safety opens up on a cyclical lender heading into eventual cuts and CRE noise.
Forensic checks Derived mechanically from PNC's filed financials — not from the AI lenses
Liquidity & RunwaySelf-Funding
DilutionShare Count Shrinking
Earnings QualityGood Earnings Quality
The three lensesswitch a tab for its full read — score + evidence
Company Quality
+42
Solid
edge √Σ 87 · risk √Σ 42 · conf 7/10

PNC is a mature earner: revenue grew from 19.21B in 2021 to 23.08B in 2025, net income rose from 5.67B to 6.94B, and diluted shares shrank at a -1.7% CAGR from 446.8M to 418.1M. OCF/NI of 1.31x and accruals of -0.3% of assets indicate clean, cash-backed earnings. FCF is positive every year (4.38B in 2025) though it stepped down from the 7-10B range of 2022-2024, worth understanding but not alarming for a bank where FCF is a noisy metric. The Altman Z of 0.31 flags 'distress' mechanically, but the model is not meaningful for banks - their business model requires high leverage and the score should be disregarded here. Insider activity is neutral: routine director awards and one small 302K sale by an officer, no directional signal. Buyback discipline is a genuine positive - roughly 7% of the float retired over five years while earnings grew. What we cannot see from this data: credit quality trends, deposit mix stability post-2023 regional-bank stress, CRE exposure, and capital ratios (CET1). Those are the real quality questions for any bank and none of them are visible in this brief.

Strengths 3
m55
Per-share concentration
Diluted shares down from 446.8M (2021) to 418.1M (2025), -1.7% CAGR, net buyer of stock while paying a dividend.
m50
Clean earnings quality
OCF/NI 1.31x, accruals -0.3% of assets, net income 5.67B to 6.94B over five years - earnings are cash-backed.
m45
Revenue and NI growth resumed in 2025
Revenue jumped from 20.81B (2024) to 23.08B (2025) and NI from 5.89B to 6.94B, best year of the window.
Concerns 3
m30
FCF stepped down
FCF fell to 4.38B in 2025 from 7.88B (2024) and a 9-10B run in 2022-2023; needs explanation though bank FCF is noisy.
m25
Net debt position
Net cash -17.39B; typical for a bank but means the balance sheet is a constraint requiring confidence in credit book and capital ratios not shown here.
m15
Altman Z 0.31 flag is a false positive
Z-score is not calibrated for banks; noting so the reader does not overweight it.
This looks like a normal, well-run super-regional bank - not exciting, not troubled. The numbers I can see (growing NI, buybacks, clean accruals, positive FCF every year) are consistent with a solid mature earner. The Altman distress flag is a model artifact for banks and I would ignore it. What I genuinely do not know from this brief is the credit book and capital position, which are the only things that ever really break a bank. Absent those, I grade this Solid with room to move up to Strong if capital ratios and credit trends check out, or down to Mixed if there is an unseen CRE or deposit problem.
Verify before trusting this (7)
  • CET1 and other regulatory capital ratios and trend
  • Non-performing loans, net charge-offs, and reserve coverage
  • Commercial real estate exposure, especially office
  • Deposit mix (non-interest bearing vs interest bearing) and beta since 2023
  • AOCI hit from held-to-maturity securities book and unrealized loss position
  • Why 2025 FCF dropped to 4.38B vs 7-10B in prior three years
  • Efficiency ratio trend and expense discipline
Valuation / Mispricing
-37
Fairly Valued
edge √Σ 15 · risk √Σ 54 · conf 8/10
Price $252.56 vs deserved ~$252-255, roughly 0-1% - no margin of safety either way. attractive below $215.00

Composite FV $252.17 and signal-adjusted FV $254.69 versus a $252.56 price = under 1% upside. The anchored-PE method ($252.17) is the appropriate lens for a mature regional bank and matches spot almost exactly. Earnings quality is good (no haircut needed) and business quality is solid, which supports the current multiple but does not manufacture a discount. Bull (rate tailwind, sticky deposits) and bear (NIM compression, CRE exposure) narratives roughly offset, which is exactly what a fairly-valued steady compounder looks like. To find real edge here you would need a materially lower entry or a differentiated view on credit or NIM that the brief does not support.

Cheap signals 1
m15
Clean earnings quality
Good earnings-quality score means no haircut to deserved value; the $252 anchor is trustworthy, not flattered by accruals.
Rich / priced-in 2
m48
No margin of safety
Signal-adjusted FV $254.69 implies ~1% upside; that is inside the noise band and offers no cushion against credit or NIM disappointment.
m25
Cyclical bank at mid-cycle multiple
Regional banks historically trade at wider discounts when rate-cut cycles begin; paying full deserved value ahead of that removes optionality.
Fairly valued, full stop. At $252.56 versus a $252-255 deserved band I have no edge - the market has priced this steady compounder correctly. I would need it closer to $215 (roughly 15% lower) to get a real margin of safety on a cyclical lender heading into an eventual rate-cut cycle with CRE overhang. Owning here is fine if you already do; buying here is paying retail.
Verify before trusting this (4)
  • CET1 ratio and capital return capacity in latest 10-Q
  • CRE and office loan concentration, reserve coverage, and non-performing trends
  • Deposit beta and NIM guidance from most recent earnings call
  • Latest buyback pace vs dilution from stock comp
General Sentiment
+33
Tailwind
tail √Σ 82 · head √Σ 47 · conf 6/10

The macro tape is friendly: VIX at 14.9, S&P at highs, and a building risk-on regime. That helps regional banks broadly, and PNC in particular is being grouped by financial media with BAC and USB as names printing new highs near technical buy points - that is the definition of positive non-fundamental flow for a boring compounder that usually gets no airtime. With beta 0.9 the macro help is moderate, not turbocharged, but it lands on the right side of the ledger.

Tailwinds 3
m55
Technical/media callout at new highs
IBD-style 'new high, near buy point' coverage clustering PNC with BAC and USB pulls momentum-following and technical money into the name - meaningful for a low-cult, low-intensity story stock that normally has no narrative bid.
m45
Risk-on tape with low VIX
VIX 14.9 and S&P at highs is a supportive backdrop for cyclicals including regional banks, though beta 0.9 means PNC only partially captures the risk-on lift.
m40
Momentum regime
Recent 10.9% run vs 3.6% long-term CAGR and +4.1pp over three years indicates the tape has quietly re-rated PNC higher; trend-followers and index flows reinforce that.
Headwinds 3
m35
Rate-cut narrative overhang
10y at 4.69% with a barely positive curve keeps the 'NIM compression when cuts arrive' bear story alive as a latent headwind on regional-bank sentiment, even if not acute today.
m25
CRE tail risk narrative
Commercial real estate concerns remain a background bear talking point for any large regional; low intensity now but capable of flaring on a single headline.
m20
Minimal narrative intensity
With a sleepy 'steady-compounder' story and low cult coefficient, PNC lacks a story-driven bid; upside from sentiment is capped versus AI or growth cohorts capturing the risk-on flow.
Net, sentiment leans positive but not dramatically so. The tape is calm and risk-on, PNC is being singled out by momentum media at new highs alongside BAC and USB, and there is no active bear narrative doing damage. Offsetting that: the story is boring by design, cult is low, and the latent rate-cut/CRE bear case is one bad print away from waking up. I read it as a genuine tailwind - moderate size, driven more by technical/flow attention than by any narrative fire.
Verify before trusting this (4)
  • Whether regional bank leadership (BAC, USB, PNC) holds the breakout or fails back into range
  • Any shift in rate-cut timing that would reprice NIM expectations for regionals
  • Fresh CRE loss headlines from peer banks that could re-ignite the sector bear narrative
  • Analyst target revisions post-recent-strength - upgrades would confirm the tailwind
The market-wide tape + this name's exposure to it (beta / sector / narrative durability). Context on the non-fundamental pressure — not a call on the business or the price. processId: detail-general-sentiment
Please log in to view trade setups
The Augustus trade-setup read is a members feature.
Log in
Three lenses kept deliberately separate — Company Quality (price-agnostic), Valuation (price-conditional), and General Sentiment (non-fundamental macro/narrative pressure). The scores are not blended. Filing-level items (convertibles, lock-ups, customer concentration) are v2 — see each lens's "verify."
Character & Durability Scorecard
Ten long-horizon business-character traits the Quality / Value / Sentiment lenses don’t break out, scored 1–10.
Scored Aug 9, 2026 12:48am
Survivability 8/10

Strong earnings continuity through multiple economic cycles with proven ability to absorb shocks, though Altman Z score reflects bank-specific capital structure rather than true distress risk.

  • Sustained positive net income through 2021-2025 ($5.58B-$6.94B range) including pandemic period
  • PNC is a top-tier regional bank that navigated 2008 financial crisis and acquired National City during distress
confidence: high · data + knowledge
Adaptability 7/10

Demonstrated ability to execute strategic pivots through M&A and technology modernization, though execution has been methodical rather than transformational.

  • Successfully integrated major acquisitions including BBVA USA franchise (2021) expanding regional footprint
  • Transitioned business model toward fee-based revenue and digital banking capabilities
confidence: medium · general knowledge
Moat Trajectory 6/10

Stable but not widening moat as digital disruption offsets traditional relationship banking advantages, maintaining solid but not expanding competitive position.

  • Regional banking franchise benefits from switching costs and local relationships
  • Competitive pressure from fintech and national players eroding traditional advantages
confidence: medium · general knowledge
Capital Allocation 7/10

Consistent shareholder-friendly capital deployment through buybacks that reduced share count meaningfully, though bank capital allocation is constrained by regulatory minimums.

  • Share count reduced from 446.8M to 418.1M (6.4% reduction) over 2021-2025 period
  • Maintained capital returns while navigating rate cycle and regulatory requirements
confidence: high · from our data
Pricing Power 5/10

Limited intrinsic pricing power as revenues swing with interest rate environment and competitive deposit pricing pressures rather than firm's ability to command premiums.

  • Revenue increased from $19.21B (2021) to $23.08B (2025) but with volatility including 2024 dip to $20.81B
  • Bank pricing power is interest-rate dependent rather than firm-controlled
confidence: medium · from our data
Management Alignment 6/10

Reasonable alignment evidenced by shareholder-friendly capital actions and minimal insider selling, though lacks strong insider ownership signals to score higher.

  • Insider activity neutral with minimal selling ($302,634 on $100B+ market cap)
  • Executed consistent buybacks reducing share count 1.7% CAGR
confidence: medium · from our data
Demand Durability 7/10

Durable demand for core banking services with growth in commercial and wealth segments, though traditional branch-based banking faces secular pressure from digitization.

  • Banking services remain essential with secular growth in commercial lending and wealth management
  • Regional banks face structural headwinds from consolidation and digital competition
confidence: high · general knowledge
Growth Consistency 5/10

Uneven growth with meaningful revenue volatility and sharply declining FCF in 2025, reflecting cyclical sensitivity and rate environment dependence rather than steady compounding.

  • Revenue trajectory: $19.21B, $21.11B, $21.51B, $20.81B, $23.08B - shows volatility with 2024 dip
  • Net income range $5.58B-$6.94B shows stability but FCF highly erratic: $7.21B to $10.11B down to $4.38B
confidence: high · from our data
Optionality / Runway 6/10

Moderate growth options through wealth management expansion and potential acquisitions, but mature core franchise with limited TAM expansion versus established footprint.

  • Expansion runway in wealth management and corporate banking segments
  • Geographic footprint provides M&A consolidation opportunities in regional banking
confidence: medium · general knowledge
Concentration / Key-Person Risk 7/10

Well-diversified business model across products and customer segments with multiple revenue streams, though regional geographic concentration creates some single-market exposure.

  • Diversified regional bank across retail, corporate, and asset management with no single customer dominance
  • Geographic concentration primarily in mid-Atlantic and Midwest regions
confidence: low · general knowledge
Scorecard v1 · 10 = most favorable for a long-term owner (incl. lower concentration risk). Some attributes draw on general knowledge where our data is thin — see each row's source tag.
Community AI Feedback
No community reviews yet for PNC. Be the first — hit How to Contribute, have any AI review this page, and paste its take back here.
My Notes personal — only you see this
Data via Financial Modeling Prep · Cached for performance · twelvedata
v1.1.515 · 9f7cac68 · 2026-08-08 13:09:58